Framework

Measure. Improve. Excel.

We know that even great processes can be made better. And we have the expertise, experience, and data to do it.

Comprehensive software development process improvement

The BetterSoftware Software Engineering Effectiveness Framework

A Quantitative Framework for Measuring and Improving Software Engineering

The BetterSoftware Software Engineering Effectiveness Framework is a quantitative framework for assessing, measuring, and continuously improving how effectively a software organization develops and delivers software.

It evaluates the complete Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC) across 35 engineering competencies, using objective practices, measurable outcomes, and a 10-level maturity scale from G through A4.

The framework is designed to work on top of an organization’s existing development methodology, tools, and processes. It does not prescribe how teams should develop software. Instead, it provides a systematic way to determine how effectively their existing engineering system is working—and where it can be improved.

Why Software Engineering Needs a System-Level View

Software organizations typically measure many individual aspects of engineering: delivery dates, defects, test coverage, velocity, incidents, pull requests, or developer activity.

Each provides useful information, but none provides a complete picture of engineering effectiveness.

Software is produced by an interconnected system. Requirements affect architecture. Architecture affects implementation. Implementation affects verification. Problems introduced in one part of the lifecycle may not become visible until much later.

The BetterSoftware Framework therefore evaluates the complete engineering system, rather than optimizing individual activities in isolation.

The objective is to answer a simple question:

How effectively does the organization convert engineering effort into successful software?

35 Software Engineering Competencies

The framework divides the SDLC into 35 measurable engineering competencies spanning the software lifecycle.

These cover the major activities required to define, design, build, integrate, verify, release, and maintain software, together with the engineering infrastructure and supporting practices required to execute them effectively.

Each competency is treated as an engineering capability that can be:

defined → measured → controlled → improved

This allows an organization to identify where it is already performing strongly, where effectiveness is being lost, and where improvement is most likely to produce meaningful results.

Rather than producing a single abstract maturity score, the framework creates a detailed view of engineering effectiveness across the lifecycle.

A 10-Level Maturity Scale

Each competency is evaluated using a 10-level maturity scale ranging from G through A4.

The scale represents progression from activities that are largely uncontrolled or inconsistently executed toward activities that are quantitatively managed, continuously improving, and operating at increasingly high levels of effectiveness.

The objective is not for every competency to achieve the highest possible level.

Different organizations, products, risks, and business environments require different levels of engineering maturity. The framework helps organizations determine where additional maturity creates meaningful business and engineering value.

This makes maturity a management decision rather than a certification exercise.

Measuring Outcomes, Not Just Activities

The existence of an engineering practice does not prove that it is effective.

A team may perform code reviews while repeatedly discovering the same problems. It may execute thousands of automated tests while maintaining unstable test suites. It may have formal requirements processes while requirements defects continue to escape into later development stages.

The BetterSoftware Framework therefore combines engineering practices with quantitative KPIs and trends.

For each competency, the objective is to determine not only whether the activity is being performed, but whether its results demonstrate that the activity is becoming more effective over time.

This creates a fundamental distinction between:

“We do it.”

and:

“We know it works.”

Fixed at Injection: Improving Problems at Their Source

A central principle of the BetterSoftware Framework is Fixed at Injection.

Software problems should be traced back to the stage of the lifecycle where they were introduced—not simply addressed where they were eventually detected.

A defect discovered during system testing may have originated in requirements. An integration failure may have originated in architecture. A production incident may expose a weakness introduced much earlier in the lifecycle.

Correcting only the immediate defect restores the product.

Correcting the engineering weakness that created it improves the system that produces the product.

By measuring where problems originate and systematically reducing their recurrence, organizations can shift quality activities earlier in the lifecycle and reduce downstream rework.

Acceptance Criteria and Quality Gates

Every significant engineering activity should have a clear definition of what is required before work begins and what must be true before its output moves forward.

The BetterSoftware Framework uses acceptance criteria and quality gates to establish these controls throughout the SDLC.

Acceptance criteria define whether the inputs to an activity are sufficient for the activity to begin effectively.

Quality gates determine whether its outputs are sufficiently complete and correct to progress to the next stage.

This prevents incomplete or low-quality engineering artifacts from simply moving downstream, where problems become progressively more expensive to detect and correct.

Continuous Improvement as an Engineering Deliverable

Assessments identify opportunities. They do not create improvement.

The BetterSoftware Framework therefore treats continuous improvement as part of normal engineering delivery, rather than as a separate transformation initiative.

Engineering teams identify measurable improvement opportunities, implement changes within their normal development cadence, and verify whether those changes improve the relevant engineering outcomes.

The cycle is straightforward:

Measure → Identify → Improve → Verify → Measure again

This allows improvement to be managed with the same rigor as product delivery.

Over time, engineering leaders can see not only whether software is being delivered, but whether the organization producing that software is becoming more effective.

Relationship to ISO/IEC/IEEE 12207

The BetterSoftware Framework is aligned with the lifecycle structure and engineering activities described by ISO/IEC/IEEE 12207, the international standard for software lifecycle processes.

The framework translates lifecycle activities into measurable engineering competencies, practices, KPIs, acceptance criteria, quality gates, and improvement activities.

It is not a replacement for ISO/IEC/IEEE 12207, nor does using the framework constitute certification against the standard.

Instead, it provides organizations with a practical quantitative system for managing the effectiveness of software engineering activities across the lifecycle.

Independent of Methodology and Tooling

The BetterSoftware Framework does not require organizations to replace their existing development methodology or toolchain.

It can be applied to organizations using Agile, SAFe, waterfall, hybrid development models, or organization-specific processes.

Likewise, it does not depend on a particular requirements tool, source-code platform, CI/CD environment, testing system, programming language, or technology stack.

The framework measures whether the engineering system produces effective outcomes—not which tools or methodology it uses to produce them.

Software Engineering Effectiveness in the Age of AI

AI is changing how software engineering activities are performed, but it does not remove the need to control them.

Requirements can be generated faster. Designs can be produced faster. Code, tests, documentation, and analysis can increasingly be created or assisted by AI.

This increases the importance of knowing whether the outputs of those activities are correct and whether weaknesses are propagating through the lifecycle.

The BetterSoftware Framework applies the same principle whether work is performed by a human, assisted by AI, or largely performed by an AI agent:

Control the inputs. Define the expected outputs. Measure the results. Prevent problems from progressing downstream.

As engineering execution becomes faster and increasingly automated, these controls become more important—not less.

From Baseline to Measurable Improvement

Applying the BetterSoftware Framework begins by establishing an objective baseline of the organization’s current engineering effectiveness.

The baseline identifies strengths, weaknesses, and differences across competencies and teams.

From there, organizations can prioritize improvements based on their own business objectives, engineering risks, and measurable outcomes rather than attempting to improve everything simultaneously.

Progress is then measured over time.

This creates a common quantitative language for engineering teams and leadership to discuss:

  • where engineering effectiveness is being lost;

  • which improvements should be prioritized;

  • whether implemented changes are working; and

  • whether the engineering organization is becoming more effective.

The Goal: A Better Engineering System

The objective of the BetterSoftware Framework is not process compliance.

It is not to maximize maturity scores, introduce additional bureaucracy, or force every engineering organization to work in the same way.

The objective is to create an engineering system that can measure itself, identify where effectiveness is being lost, improve those areas, and verify that the improvements actually work.

That is what turns continuous improvement from an aspiration into a measurable engineering discipline.

Deep Insights​

Leverage your historical data, industry benchmarks, and over 20 competencies to gain immediate access to trends, recurring bottlenecks, blockers, and progress.

Expert Guidance

Receive tailored guidance and recommendations based on a universal model derived from the largest database of software improvement plans.

Executive Overview

Provide senior management with clear visibility into different competencies, improvement areas, and strengths within the organization.

Proven Success

Achieve measurable improvements in productivity and defect reductions, with many companies seeing up to a 25% increase in effectiveness annually.

Seamless Integration

Our framework integrates effortlessly with your existing workflow, making it easy to implement and sustain improvements.

System Optimization

Tackle every stage of the software development lifecycle and gain control over complex software systems, ensuring process enhancement and efficient software delivery.

Why choose BetterSoftware?

Our framework is meticulously designed to help businesses refine their software development processes, embrace a culture of continuous improvement, and consistently deliver exceptional software. With BetterSoftware, you gain access to cutting-edge analytics and process mining technologies that provide detailed insights and actionable guidance, ensuring your team excels at every stage of development.

For Large Enterprises

BetterSoftware is designed for enterprises with complex software development operations. It scales effortlessly across various teams and departments, ensuring smooth collaboration and data flow. 

Compatible with All Tools

The framework seamlessly integrates with your current development environment and adapts to your teams’ specific tools or languages. It leverages your existing data to provide invaluable insights and recommendations. 

Enhancing Any Methodology

Our framework integrates with any approach, from traditional waterfall to agile and hybrid methods. It enhances the effectiveness of your chosen methodology, serving as an invaluable guide.

Claim your free initial team
effectiveness scan

Let’s determine the best and most efficient path to software excellence together.

Align on the scope on a brief 20-minute call.

Your benefits:
What happens next?
1

We schedule a call at your convenience

2

We hold a discovery meeting

3

We run a complimentary proof of concept

Request Your Free Scan

Partner with us for software excellence success